Solid Vs. Hollow Vs. Dissolving Vs. Coated Microneedles: Which Is Best For Drug Delivery?
Aug 22, 2026
Introduction
Microneedle-based drug delivery has emerged as a transformative transdermal technology that uniquely combines the simplicity of a patch with the efficacy of subcutaneous injection. By creating microscopic channels across the stratum corneum, microneedles (MNs) enable efficient penetration of therapeutic agents into the skin while maintaining minimal invasiveness, ease of use, and excellent biocompatibility. These advantages have attracted enormous attention from the global research community.
This article focuses on the classification and functional principles of microneedles, drawing primarily from the work of Xiaowen Liu and Fei Xiao (Jinan University) and Bin Du (Tongji University), titled "Microneedle-mediated drug delivery for cutaneous diseases,"published in Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology.
Figure 1. Classification of microneedles and their respective transdermal delivery mechanisms.
1. Solid Microneedles (SMNs)
Overview
Solid microneedles are typically used for skin pre-treatment prior to the application of active pharmaceutical ingredients. They operate on the classic poke-and-patchprinciple: creating transient microchannels that enhance the permeability of subsequently applied topical formulations.
Materials
Common fabrication materials include:
|
Material Category |
Specific Examples |
|---|---|
|
Polymers |
Poly(methyl vinyl ether/maleic anhydride) (PMVE/MA), poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), poly(lactic acid) (PLA) |
|
Metals |
Stainless steel, titanium, nickel |
|
Silicon-based |
Silicon wafers via MEMS processing |
Mechanism & Advantages
Create instantaneous, uniform microchannels in the stratum corneum
Significantly improve local drug penetration efficiency
High mechanical stiffness ensures reliable skin insertion
Relatively simple and low-cost to manufacture
Limitations
Channels close within hours due to natural skin healing, limiting sustained release
Risk of needle fracture and residual fragments in the skin
No intrinsic drug-carrying capacity-requires a separate drug reservoir
Figure 2. Schematic and representative SEM image of solid microneedles.
2. Hollow Microneedles (HMNs)
Overview
Unlike solid structures, hollow microneedles feature an internal lumen or bore (diameter: ~50–70 μm) that runs through the needle shaft-essentially functioning as microscale hypodermic syringes.
Materials
Silicon (via MEMS fabrication)
Glass (via draw lithography)
Polymers (via micro-molding or 3D printing)
Mechanism & Advantages
The internal cavity can be pre-loaded with therapeutic agents and delivers them via pressure-driven flow upon insertion
Capable of carrying larger fluid volumes than any other MN type
Enables precise, controllable dosing-ideal for macromolecules, vaccines, and even interstitial fluid extraction for diagnostics
Suitable for a wide range of active molecules
Limitations
Fabrication is significantly more complex (requires digital micro-electro-mechanical systems)
Dermal tissue tightness may cause lumen clogging during insertion
Higher manufacturing cost and longer production time
Figure 3. Schematic and working principle of hollow microneedles.
3. Dissolving Microneedles (DMNs)
Overview
Dissolving microneedles are fabricated entirely from water-soluble, biodegradable materials embedded with therapeutic agents. Upon insertion, the needle matrix dissolves or degrades in situ, releasing the payload directly into the skin-no removal or disposal step required.
Materials
- Sugars: Maltose, trehalose
- Natural polymers: Hyaluronic acid (HA), dextran, gelatin
- Synthetic biodegradable polymers: PLGA, PVA, PVP
-
Mechanism & Advantages
- Excellent biocompatibility and safety profile
- No sharp medical waste-entire device dissolves, eliminating biohazard disposal
Significantly improves patient compliance; suitable for self-administration
Provides a new paradigm for long-term, chronic disease management
Extensively researched for diverse conditions: cancer, diabetes, psoriasis, vaccine delivery, and more
Limitations
Mechanical strength must be carefully balanced with dissolution rate
Drug stability during storage and the fabrication process requires optimization
Drug loading capacity is finite and depends on matrix composition
Figure 4. Dissolving microneedle structure and in-skin degradation process.
4. Coated Microneedles (CMNs)
Overview
Coated microneedles are solid MNs with a therapeutic coating applied to the needle surface. The drug is released as the coating dissolves or detaches upon skin contact.
Coating Methods
|
Method |
Process Description |
|---|---|
|
Dip-Coating |
Microneedles are immersed into a target coating solution, allowing the active ingredient to adhere to the surface as the solvent evaporates |
|
Spray-Coating |
An atomizer or gas-jet device sprays the active formulation onto the MN surface, enabling uniform thin-film coverage |
Mechanism & Advantages
Rapid drug release immediately upon insertion
Precise dose control-the amount of drug delivered is determined by coating thickness and surface area
Simple to operate; well-suited for high-potency, low-dose drugs (e.g., vaccines, peptides)
Cost-effective and scalable
Limitations
Drug loading is limited by the surface area of the microneedle
Coating may detach during insertion or degrade during storage
Ensuring uniform coating thickness and long-term stability remains a formulation challenge
Figure 5. Coated microneedle fabrication via dip-coating and spray-coating methods.
Summary Comparison
|
Type |
Delivery Mode |
Key Strength |
Primary Limitation |
Typical Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Solid (SMN) |
Poke-and-patch |
High stiffness; simple |
No intrinsic drug; transient channels |
Skin pre-treatment; small-molecule enhancement |
|
Hollow (HMN) |
Pressure-driven flow |
Highest loading; precise dosing |
Complex & costly fabrication; clogging risk |
Macromolecule delivery; ISF extraction |
|
Dissolving (DMN) |
In-situ degradation |
No waste; excellent compliance |
Mechanical strength vs. dissolution balance |
Chronic diseases; vaccines; cancer |
|
Coated (CMN) |
Surface coating dissolution |
Rapid release; dose-accurate |
Surface-area-limited loading |
Vaccines; short-acting peptides |
Concluding Remarks
Each MN architecture offers a distinct set of trade-offs in terms of drug capacity, release kinetics, manufacturing complexity, and clinical suitability. Understanding these differences is essential for matching the right MN platform to the right therapeutic application-particularly in the rapidly growing field of microneedle-mediated drug delivery for cutaneous diseases.
As materials science and microfabrication continue to advance, we can expect even more sophisticated hybrid designs that combine the best features of all four types-bringing us closer to truly personalized, painless, and precision transdermal therapy.







